February 22, 1970 [Au hasard Balthazar]
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/381d8/381d86ae9d4db068df1147938215913089b0847e" alt=""
And what is necessary? Is it suffering? Balthazar the donkey suffers the whims of demons, punks and madmen--and the girl who grows with him, her love promised, her mercy unfulfilled. What else is there? Yearning? For what? To be left alone, to spend a day un-harried? Or to be loved, despite all other miseries? It’s almost a joke, this movie, punctuated by braying and close-ups of the animal’s eye—and Christ how I wished I could be looking into other eyes, Mr. Ed’s or Francis the Talking Mule. But no: Bresson reaches farther back, to Pinocchio and Pleasure Island, and Lampwick the bad little boy twisted like something out of Ovid, punished for next to nothing--his own whim is all, a boy’s indulgences, for God’s sake--and forced down on all fours to hee-haw like a damned thing, the shadows rising like the sound of his new voice.
And is that what set my tears to flowing at the end?--the movie done for a good ten seconds before suddenly I couldn’t stop myself, and I sat there like a kid, my hand over my mouth, my eyes closed, while the audience slipped away and I cried for--I know, I know: me, like poor Lampwick also now a donkey.
And is that all I was going to take away from this? Pity for poor poor me? I shook my head and opened my eyes and thought about the girl, grown up and hoping for love--but getting rough lips swiping at her mouth like a shove to send her backward into a gone childhood, an empty room that isn’t even hers anymore--but she has to live in it, forever.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8c86a/8c86a4e06481c0b80424538221b7c4d3eda792f8" alt=""
Comments
Post a Comment